Have you ever wondered how to get that perfect eye look without spending hours in front of the mirror? Then it’s time to start carrying an eyeshadow stick in your beauty bag. Whether you’re after a soft, everyday look or something bold for a night out, these sticks have got your back. And guess what? I’ve been on the hunt for the best ones that not only complement every skin tone but also bring out the beauty in every eye color. So scroll on to find the best eyeshadow sticks that promise to deliver both ease and elegance to your beauty routine!
Tarte Tartelette Shadow Stick
The Tarte Tartelette Shadow Stick Set, especially with the QVC-exclusive holiday edition, is a treasure for both the “less is more” and “go big or go home” kind of beauty enthusiasts. Originally priced at $48 and now a steal at $39.98 on QVC (who doesn’t love a good deal?), this set is a serious bang for your buck given that purchasing each stick individually would cost you around $115.
Now, let’s talk about what’s inside. These sticks boast a waterproof formula enriched with Amazonian clay. The creamy gel texture makes application a breeze, smoothly delivering rich, buildable color. The set’s shades variety is a standout feature, offering a bronze copper for a warm, sun-kissed effect, a golden taupe that’s perfect for adding subtle sophistication, a matte mauve for a softer, everyday look, and a shimmering champagne ideal for highlighting and brightening. These shades are incredibly versatile, flattering a wide range of skin tones and eye colors. They glide on effortlessly but take note—you might need a stronger remover for the day’s end. However, their all-day staying power is quite impressive.
e.l.f. No Budge Shadow Stick
Sensitive or mature eyes, fair or pale skin, e.l.f. No Budge Shadow Stick will enhance your natural look, being one of the best (and most affordable) eyeshadow sticks you can find at your local drugstore. The name speaks for itself—this shadow stick doesn’t budge. Whether you’re battling the relentless Florida humidity or just going about your day, it stays put without smudging or creasing. Moreover, the formula is creamy and blendable, perfect for a fuss-free application that can stand alone or act as a base for other eye colors. What do I particularly love about this product? It’s 100% vegan and cruelty-free, a big win in my book. However, although there’s enough variety in shades to play around with, this one leans more toward shimmer pigment. If you’re after a bolder, more pigmented look, this might not be your first pick. However, for someone like me who leans towards a natural look, it’s a perfect fit.
Julep Crème to Powder Eyeshadow Stick
This one is an Amazon best-seller with nearly five stars across a staggering 41,000 reviews. And it’s easy to see why. It offers something for everyone, boasting over 30 high-pigmented shades ranging from matte to shimmer and metallic finishes. These shades cater to all—whether you have green or blue eyes, fair or dark skin, this eyeshadow stick has you covered. Plus, it’s suitable for sensitive eyes.
But here’s where it gets even more interesting: this eyeshadow doubles as skincare, thanks to the nourishing formula enriched with vitamins C and E. The waterproof and crease-free formula is another win, especially if you struggle with the thin, delicate skin around your eyes. Unlike some shadows that can leave a cakey, dry appearance accentuating fine lines, this creamy shadow applies smoothly and maintains a non-cakey look. My only caveat is the staying power; it doesn’t quite last as long as some other shadow sticks I’ve tried. A primer might be a good ally for longer wear. But for an eyeshadow that avoids the messy fallout of powder shadows and feels comfortable on the skin, it’s worth it.
Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Cream Eyeshadow Stick
Ever had that eyeshadow that promises the world but gives you a raccoon eye by noon? Well, this isn’t that. It’s creamy, yes, but it stays put all day—no smudging or creasing, even if you’re running around. And when it’s time to take it off, a double round with your cleanser should do the trick. It’s pretty user-friendly, especially if you’re not big on brushes—just use and blend with your fingers. The best part? Bobbi Brown Cream Eyeshadow Stick works wonders on mature skin, gliding on without settling into fine lines.
How to pick eyeshadow colors
The general rule is to use shades that contrast with your eye color while harmonizing with your skin tone. For instance, if you have a warm skin tone, go for warm shades like bronze, peach, or golden brown. Cooler skin tones shine with cooler shades like silvery blue or lavender.
- Blue eyes: To make your blue eyes stand out, try eyeshadows in warm tones like copper, gold, or peach. Copper brings out the vibrancy in blue eyes with its rich warmth, gold adds a luxurious shimmer, and peach offers a subtle, soft contrast
- Blue eyes with blonde hair: This combination often works best with soft, muted shades like light brown or soft pink. Avoid anything too dark; you want to enhance your features, not overshadow them.
- Green eyes: Green eyes are versatile but look particularly stunning with shades of purple and mauve. These colors bring out the richness of the green.
- Green eyes with fair skin: For green eyes with fair skin, consider soft, earthy tones like a gentle moss green or a muted bronze. These shades complement both the eye color and the lightness of the skin.
- Brown eyes: Brown eyes can handle a range of colors, but to bring out their warmth, try rich shades like espresso, bronze, or even a bold blue.
- Brown eyes with dark hair: You can play with contrast here–think rich plums, deep greens, or even metallic shades for a bit of drama.
How to use eyeshadow sticks
Start with the eyeshadow before applying eyeliner or mascara. This order allows you to create a cohesive look, where the eyeliner enhances and defines the shadow rather than competing with it.
Glide the shadow stick along your lash line if you’re aiming for a defined, liner-like effect. For a more traditional eyeshadow look, apply it all over your eyelid. The beauty of eyeshadow sticks is in their blendability—you can smudge them for a softer look or layer them for more intensity. Once you’ve applied the eyeshadow stick, give it a moment to set. After your eyeshadow has set, you can proceed with eyeliner to define your eyes. The liner can go right along the lash line for a defined look or can be smudged for a smokier effect. Finally, finish off with mascara to make your lashes stand out.
