11 Best Organic Eye Creams We Can’t Get Enough Of

Brand courtesy / Biossance
We may include products - handpicked by our editors - we find useful for our readers. When you buy through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission — view our product review process and sources of information.

With skin that’s so delicate and fragile around the eyes, no wonder you’re trying to find the best organic eye cream. Pollution, stress, lack of oil glands all have a part in wreaking havoc on your under-eye skin, making a host for crow’s feet, dark circles, and puffiness. Being 40% thinner than the rest of the complexion, the skin around the eyes easily reacts to lack of sleep, environmental damage, and age. So you’re looking for a gentle cream that’s not formulated with potentially drying or irritating ingredients but with natural extracts, aka an organic eye cream.

What to look for in an organic eye cream

You want to avoid parabens, alcohol, synthetic fragrances, phthalates, sulfates, aluminum, synthetic fragrances, as they’re overly drying and potentially irritating. Instead, look for the addition of vitamins A, C, E, shea butter, caffeine, avocado extract, jojoba, and coconut oil, which work to restore moisture and protect your under-eye skin while nourishing it with vital nutrients. Also, look for highly concentrated products that retain the skin’s moisture while maintaining firmness and elasticity.

The best organic eye creams

Whether you want to brighten dark circles, plump fine lines, or correct puffiness, here are the best natural and organic eye creams that work hard to deliver visible results instantly and over time.

L'Occitane Immortelle Precious Eye Balm

L’Occitane Immortelle Precious Eye Balm

To say farewell to fine lines around the eyes, the L’Occitane Precious Eye Balm is what you need. The star ingredients in its formula are the organic Immortelle essential oil, hyaluronic acid, and shea butter that work to plump fine lines and crow’s feet in the blink of an eye. It has a super-rich balm texture, creating an invisible film that keeps the eye area protected and hydrated all day long, all without the sticky feeling.

Juice Beauty Stem Cellular Eye Treatment

Juice Beauty Stem Cellular Eye Treatment

Another of the best organic eye creams comes from Juice Beauty, a brand I’m totally fond of. The formula is actually a rich gel-like cream that gives your eye area a refreshing feeling. And since it’s infused with a blend of natural fruit juices, shea butter-derived fatty acids, plus vitamins B5, C, and E, the skin stays nourished, plumped, and protected. On top of everything, the brightening properties of apple fruit cells, vitamin C, and lemon extract work to diminish puffiness and dark circles look.

BABOR Cleanformance Awakening Eye Cream

Babor Cleanformance Awakening Eye Cream

Babor products are easy to love and this eye cream is one of their best hit. It’s filled with antioxidants from red maple bark, pre- and probiotics to restore skin’s microbiome, niacinamide to diminish dar circles, and hyaluronic acid to replenish hydration. The quick-absorbing and lightweight formula is created with 95% naturally derived ingredients, it’s all vegan and dermatologist-tested. And with the addition of light-reflecting pigments, it diminishes the look of dark circles for a luminous, well-rested glow. Sold!

Biossance natural eye cream

Biossance Lifting Eye Treatment

Biossance puts on the table another best organic eye cream formulated with squalane and marine algae. It does magic at revitalizing and softening the skin under the eyes, revealing a radiant and luminous look. If you’re not familiar with these two anti-agers, squalane is a known skin-identical ingredient that delivers long-lasting hydration, while marine algae help minimize the appearance of wrinkles and fine lines. On top of everything, this organic eye cream also contains vitamin E, peptides, and other natural extracts to nourish the skin some more. 

Caudalie Anti Aging Eye Cream

Caudalie Premier Cru Anti-Aging Eye Cream

You’ll want to use this cream every morning and night. The mix of avocado oil, caffeine, hyaluronic acid, grape seed oil, and peptide instantly plump fine lines and crow’s feet, addressing those who want to tackle a lack of firmness. Plus, the addition of soft-focus powder adds radiance to the skin, disguising dark circles and discoloration under the eye. It sinks into the skin super fast with a velvety texture, relaxing the skin while creating the perfect canvas for makeup.

Eminence Wild Plum Eye Cream

Eminence Wild Plum Eye Cream

If your goal is to get rid of dark circles around the eyes, this is your to-go organic eye cream. Formulated with iron-rich wild plum, green tea, and grape oil, it’ll make the skin appear brightened and re-energized with each application. Also packed with vitamins A, C, E, and coenzyme Q10, it acts as a protector against free radicals while hydrates in-depth. The product absorbs fast and stays in place all day, working to smooth fine lines and wrinkles. Apply it before you hit the hay and in the morning for constant hydration.

Origins Natural Eye Cream

Origins Age-Defense Eye Cream With SPF 20

SPF in your eye cream is a bright idea! And you find it in Origins Age-Defense Eye Cream. White tea antioxidant helps protect from infrared and pollution, while titanium dioxide and zinc oxide neutralize UV damaging effects. The addition of shea butter, cranberry, blueberry, wolfberry, and hyaluronic acid keeps the skin around the eyes hydrated, nourished, and plump. Sun protection and hydration in one of the best organic eye creams!

best natural eye cream 2021

AMARTÉ Skin Care Eyeconic Eye Cream

This luxurious K beauty product contains 1.0 % retinol, adenosine, argan oil, ginkgo biloba, grapefruit seed extract, and many other good-for-skin ingredients. It provides moisturizing properties and anti-wrinkles benefits to the delicate eye area with a gentle and lightweight texture. Addressing everyone who wants to target aging signs around the eyes, the breakthrough formula is enhanced with EGF 2-nano, a small polypeptide of 53 amino acids that serve to stimulate epidermal cell growth.

Ole Henriksen Banana Bright Eye Creme

Ole Henriksen Banana Bright Eye Creme

If you’re searching for a multitasking eye cream that firms, brightens, and makes it as a concealer base, your quest to find the best organic eye cream is over. Ole Henriksen Banana Bright Eye Cream targets dark circles and puffiness with vitamin C and instantly illuminates the eye area with banana powder-inspired pigments. Jojoba seed oil, shea butter, beeswax, glycerin, coconut alkanes, and collagen deliver emollient and protective properties, helping keep the skin plump, elastic, and firm.

Kiehl's Creamy Eye Treatment with Avocado

Kiehl’s Creamy Eye Treatment with Avocado

What makes Kiehl’s eye treatment one of the best organic eye creams? It’s truly like a multivitamin and antioxidants dose for your under-eye skin. The natural formula uses avocado oil, shea butter, castor oil, and beta-carotene to nourish the skin and prevent moisture loss. Slathered over the eye area, it plumps and hydrates for skin that feels elastic and firm throughout the day, keeping dryness away.

ELEMIS Peptide Eye Recovery Cream

LilyAna Naturals Stor Eye Cream

This will be your jam if you want an eye cream made with 77% organic ingredients, safe for sensitive skin, and mega-hydrating. Vitamins B3, B5, C, and E, niacinamide, hibiscus extract, rosehip oil are just a few of the ingredients that’ll take care of your eye area skin. The formula works to restore and protect, lock in moisture and minimize the wrinkles’ appearance. Cute package, pump dispenser, super affordable — no wonder it’s an Amazon best-seller with over 24,000 reviews.

Who wrote this?
Ana Vasilescu
Ana Vasilescu
Ana is a sociologist and feminist with a shared passion for literature, psychology, and skincare, the combo that made her determined to start Women's Concepts. With over five years of experience in dermatological research, she has now become a certified skincare consultant keen to convince others of the importance of a diligent routine. Her close relationships with dermatologists around the globe, along with years of researching, analyzing studies, and hand-testing products on a daily basis, made Ana one of the best persons you can get advice from.
Subscribe to our newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter to get access to exclusive content, offers, and products.
Was this article helpful?
Awesome! Would you like to share it?
That's too bad. Thank you for your feedback!
Why trust us?
Women's Concepts relies on the latest scientific research to provide accurate, complete, and fact-based information in skincare, on which we're willing to stake our reputation. Our team includes skincare experts who are highly regarded in their fields and committed to upholding the best standards of research. We spend quality time vetting every single product we recommend and double-checking all the facts shared on Women's Concepts. We always stand on the side of inclusivity, and our mission is to help everyone fix their skin issues as they arise and leverage the products they buy to achieve their goals. You can view our expert review board and everything about our editorial guidelines here.
Women's Concepts Logo
Join Us