Top 7 Organic & Natural Eyeliners for Killer Looks

Brand courtesy / ILIA Beauty
We may include products - handpicked by our editors - we find useful for our readers. When you buy through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission — view our product review process and sources of information.

From Cleopatra times to our days, everyone loves eyeliners! No matter if you’re having a messy bun, wearing foundation, or any makeup at all, a wing always changes it all, pulling you together, even if your day s****. Daily cat-eye or not, having one of the best natural eyeliners in your makeup bag is gold. It’s the best go-to product for changing your look in a matter of minutes (even if sometimes 30, ops!), perfect for day-wear or dramatic night looks. And organic eyeliners give you *the look* without the risk of getting irritated (although you should know your allergies).

What type of eyeliner should I pick?

How you like to apply eyeliner is essential to consider before purchasing one. You may want to create sharp, intense black shapes or just a smooth base for your mascara. With this in mind, you can choose from liquid eyeliners with a fine, precise tip or a soft pencil to stay true to that subtle look you want. However, we’ve rounded up all types of organic eyeliners for quick applications and dramatic looks alike. 

The bes organic eyeliners

Here I am, whittling down the best natural eyeliners from trusted brands that fully meet your expectations.  

Jane Iredale Mystikol Powdered Eyeliner
Most popular

1. Jane Iredale Mystikol Powdered Eyeliner

This waterproof eyeliner can be your go-to for long days and nights. A powder-creamy formula and a built-in brush make it easy to create perfect lines or long-lasting smokey eyes that won’t crease or smear. And it’s all-vegan, without any trace of paraben, fragrance, or other hazardous ingredients. Plus, you’ve got six shades you can choose from!

100% Pure Long Last Liquid Eye Liner
Best natural ingredients

2. 100% Pure Long Last Liquid Eye Liner

How does the idea of using an eyeliner infused with black tea, aloe vera, cocoa butter, thyme, rosemary, oregano, and honeysuckle sound to you? Welp, this eyeliner’s got all of that! As one of the best organic eyeliners, it’s made with natural pigments and nourishing ingredients, it guarantees a deep shade that won’t fade away throughout the day as it’s water-resistant. The brush tip is tiny, ideal for precision looks.

PÜR On Point Eyeliner Pencil
Best creamy feel

3. PÜR On Point Eyeliner Pencil

If you’re not into liquid eyeliners, this one may be to your liking. The waterproof formula delivers pure black color while taking care of your skin with vitamin E, ceramides, and omega fatty acids. Deeply moisturizing, this self-sharpening pencil is ocular-tested and safe for sensitive eyes. 

Chantecaille Les Perles Metallic Eye Liner
Best for metallic finish

4. Chantecaille Les Perles Metallic Eye Liner

You can’t give up on that metallic, shimmer eyeliner finish? Then go for Chantecaille! This eyeliner assures precise application with a tiny, fine tip that’s easy to control and comes in four bold shades for creative makeup looks. Parabens-, fragrance-, phthalate-free, this organic eyeliner has a water base that dries down quickly to a smooth, high-drama finish.

ILIA Natural Clean Line Gel Liner
Best gel-like formula

5. ILIA Natural Clean Line Gel Liner 

For the best organic eyeliner with a gel-like texture that goes on smooth and layers seamlessly, you can’t skip Ilia’s eyeliner. Resistant to water, it’s made without carbon, but charcoal powder for high-intensity pigment, being all-vegan. Infused with castor oil, rest assured it’ll nourish your eyelid every time you wear it!

bareMinerals Lash Domination Ink Liner
Best wallet-friendly

6. bareMinerals Lash Domination Ink Liner 

Creators of clean beauty, bareMinerals used a quinoa protein complex to nourish your lashes at the roots when wearing their eyeliner. The pencil-like applicator is just great at making thin and thick lines for all kinds of looks. Water-resistant, it even includes shaker balls to disperse pigment for a flow of rich color every time you use it — you just have to shake it before.

W3LL PEOPLE Natural Hypnotist Eyeliner
Best at easy-application

7. W3LL PEOPLE Natural Hypnotist Eyeliner 

This one performs really well at smoking out eyes, assuring it’s super easy for you to build up that wing and have control over your look. Basically, it’s a pencil enhanced with hyper-pigmented minerals for the perfect color, while the skin-loving ingredients assure a safe experience even for the most sensitive eyes. You’ll get a bold cat-eye without having to add multiple layers or worrying it’ll bleed to the lower lid.

Who wrote this?
Ana Vasilescu
Ana Vasilescu
Ana is a sociologist and feminist with a shared passion for literature, psychology, and skincare, the combo that made her determined to start Women's Concepts. With over five years of experience in dermatological research, she has now become a certified skincare consultant keen to convince others of the importance of a diligent routine. Her close relationships with dermatologists around the globe, along with years of researching, analyzing studies, and hand-testing products on a daily basis, made Ana one of the best persons you can get advice from.
Subscribe to our newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter to get access to exclusive content, offers, and products.
Was this article helpful?
Awesome! Would you like to share it?
That's too bad. Thank you for your feedback!
Women's Concepts Logo
Join Us